Karma and Rebirth - Reconciliation with Advaita
Sankara's monism is a form of Hindu philosophy. In fact, it is one of the most popular ones. It emerges in the Hindu Scriptures and was developed by the Hindu philosopher and theologian Sankara in the 8th century. Sankara, it has been argued, made the theory cogent and intelligible, consistent with other scriptural claims and even used it as a tool in an attempt to try and convert recalcitrant Buddhists.
Briefly, Sankara's monism, or Advaita as it is called, says that there is no distinction between mind and body, and besides, that there is only one mind in the universe. This non-dual mind is identified with our Self, which is our thinking soul, and also with god. Everything else, including your and my individuality, is an illusion, called Maya, in this mind due to its intrinsic ignorance about the nature of things. There need be no cause for ignorance, Sankara argues, as it occurs naturally. Only wisdom needs to be explained. Thus there is no need to posit any further entities to back this ontological thesis.
Now, post-vedic Hindu scriptures contain ample references also to the doctrine of karmic rebirth.1 That is, every being is caught in an unending cycle of births and deaths. As you sow, so you shall reap. Thus, our "sins"2 will eventually catch up with us causing us (our souls) to be reborn in our next lives and eventually (after an infinite time) experience exactly what it is we did to other creatures in this and our previous lives. This has been proposed by some as the Hindu solution to the problem of evil. A very simplistic interpretation of this doctrine (folk-rendition) says that if you kill a butterfly in this life, then you will be reborn as a butterfly in one of your future lives during which this butterfly will be born as a human who will kill you, thus evening things out in the final reckoning.
Continue reading "Karma and Rebirth - Reconciliation with Advaita" »